|
|
|
|
Seen and Heard International, 28/12/2018 |
Antoine Lévy-Leboyer |
|
Verdi: Otello, Bayerische Staatsoper, ab 23. November 2018 |
|
Verdi Meets Bergman in Munich’s Highly Recommended Otello
|
|
To fully appreciate this production of Otello one has to completely forget
past performances and conceptions. What director Amélie Niermeyer has done
is to provide a fresh, profound and convincing perspective on the work that
manages to take into account both the story and the music, as well as, the
characteristics, strengths and weaknesses of the principal singers.
The central character in Niermeyer’s conception is not Otello but Desdemona,
present right from the start during the tempest scene. Otello enters to
deliver his famous ‘Esultate’ alone, reminding us of soldiers suffering from
post-traumatic stress disorder, who keep reliving their battles in their
minds. The stage is divided into two parallel parts, and throughout the
opera the action moves frequently from Otello’s to Desdemona’s world.
Desdemona is no longer a passive, innocent victim. At the end of Act I,
she is the one kissing Otello, leading him to bed and trying to connect with
him, but the music is very clear at this moment and he is the one
reminiscing about his military exploits while she is the more tender one. At
the very start of Act II, the couple leave without exchanging a word nor a
loving glance, and one wonders if the wedding has even been consummated. In
Act III, she is a commanding figure wearing black trousers with a red
blouse.
We see before our very eyes what the work is really about: a
couple disintegrating. Bergman meets Verdi …
As always with theatre
directors, Personenregie (character development and characterisation) was
strong, but Niermeyer also took cues from the music. A highlight was the
second part of Act III, after the terrible ‘A terra!. . .e piangi’, with
subtle lighting and imaginative use of video showing how things begin to
collapse. The overall concept worked well with the singers. Anja Harteros
has wonderful emotional range in addition to beauty of voice. Kaufmann, in
this performance, displayed power in the high notes when needed. He tends to
become baritonal in the middle register, which could even surprise many who
are familiar with the Otellos of Domingo or Vickers. But it worked well
here, creating a brooding Otello. Gerald Finley was a subtle Iago, careful
with his words – one could hear echoes of the Mozart roles he has sung and
perhaps, hopefully, of an upcoming Falstaff. Minor parts were cast with
care, as is the rule in Munich. The chorus was terrific including the
children’s’ chorus in Act II, perfectly in tune.
In the pit was
Kirill Petrenko conducting his first Verdi opera. The orchestra played like
lions for him, drawing a thrilling power from the opening scenes onwards.
The cello section produced warm, glowing colours. The tempi were swift,
contributing to the dramatic feeling. Balance between stage and pit was
maintained with great care, no voice was covered at any moment. There was a
strong sense of architecture with a long musical line particularly in the
chorus passages of Act III. Petrenko truly is the leading conductor of our
time.
In spite of the cold winter weather, coughs were minimal. The
audience listened attentively. They knew what they were hearing was special,
and one could hear a pin, sorry, a handkerchief drop.
This revealing
production will be revived for the Munich Opera Festival in July 2019. It
cannot be recommended strongly enough.
|
|
|
|
|
|